What they found was that there was a fairly large gender imbalance in terms of who was submitting these Maker portfolios. The Maker Portfolio was designed to address this gap by allowing applicants to submit a supplemental portfolio of technically creative work. no comments … Indeed, portfolio submission rates increased across all portfolios for both men and women. Whatever way you slice the data at hand, however, the consistent trend is that women submit the Maker Portfolio – and only the Maker Portfolio – at a lower rate than men, and far below the rate they submit any other type of supplemental portfolio. The MIT Admissions Dept is making it possible for young makers to share their projects as part of the application process, starting this year. That’s a small 7.9% admission rate. Another possibility is that women may not identify with the Maker identity with which the Portfolio is branded. You have a short amount of time to explain your project, what you did, how you did it, and why you enjoyed it. One persistent challenge to the Maker Portfolio, however, is the fact that women submit them at a much lower rate than men do, and at a much lower rate than they submit other portfolios and apply to MIT overall, as depicted on the chart below. We note that this data does not include other possible socioeconomic intersections (e.g., by race, wealth, or parent's education) that we intend to make the subject of future research. Maker portfolio for MIT … edit subscriptions. In many respects, the Maker Portfolio has been a resounding success. According to the College Board, only 20% of the students who took the 2014 AP Computer Science (APCS) exam globally were women. I say submit one! Maker portfolio for MIT. Do you mean "requires less effort over the course of your lifetime" or "requires less effort during your senior year of high school" or what? This is a disappointing bit of obsessing by MIT's administration about an insignificant difference in behavior among students seeking admission. The question is why? 13. share. my subreddits. I think if you write a real good essay you should be able to get into Stanford or MIT with all that OSS stuff. 3. At MIT, though, this doesn’t hold true. share. could I submit a recipe I created in the maker portfolio? Members of the MIT Engineering Advisory Board… Gender Imbalance in MIT Admissions Maker Portfolios, The Wisdom and Process of Creating a MicroMaster's Credential, After the Earthquakes: MIT's Nepal Initiative, MicroMaster's Pilot: An Experiment in Educating Professionals, In Guarding the Well-Being of MIT Students, 2015 Undergraduate Enrolled Student Survey. The Maker Portfolio is an opportunity for students to showcase their projects that require creative insight, technical skill and a ‘hands-on’ approach to learning by doing. As you can see, 85.9% of all Maker Portfolios last year were submitted by men, and only 14.1% by women. i discuss my love of making that specific food in one of my essays. Does anyone have good examples? Maker Faire. Another reason is that we in Admissions are interested in community feedback on if and how we might make the Maker Portfolio seem more accessible to women (if indeed it does not at present). Well, what do you mean by "easier"? In August 2013, the Admissions Office added a Maker Portfolio supplement to the undergraduate application. There is some reason to believe that the “problem” begins before it reaches our process, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't try to do anything about it. “Every year the job of selecting among such a talented applicant pool is more and more difficult,” says Stu Schmill, MIT’s dean of admissions. User account menu. However, there are numerous schools out there that would be a good fit for you, so don't get stuck thinking only MIT is the right place for you. “I’m always so impressed by the high caliber of students who apply to MIT. 0 comments. Posted by 4 years ago. The MIT Admissions Dept is making it possible for young makers to share their projects as part of the application process, starting this year. A total of 18,357 students applied, for an admission rate of 7.7 percent. Here's my Maker Portfolio submission to MIT. best. I honestly think my maker portfolio is what got me in! No school, state, or regional quotas are applied, and we do not consider legacy/alumni relations in our process. Last November, we recorded in these pages a notable difference in the rates at which men and women submitted Maker Portfolios as supplements to their freshman applications. After the preliminary success we've seen at MIT, the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy has recommended, in its "Nation of Makers" report, that more universities consider implementing a Maker Portfolio in their admissions process. Each portfolio is reviewed at least once by a member of the Engineering Advisory Board, a body constituted by members of the faculty, instructional staff, and distinguished alumni with specific expertise and experience in particular modes of “making.” These evaluations are added to the applicant's folder for consideration in the admissions process. One reason we have chosen to publish this data is to highlight the continuing importance of identifying, acknowledging, and developing technical talent in pre-college women, and for MIT, both as an organization and as the individuals that constitute it, to maintain and improve its support for initiatives and programs that work toward these ends. Access MIT Provides Flexible Commuting Options and an Opportunity for Meaningful Personal Action, Highlights from the 2016 Faculty and Staff Quality of Life Survey, Request for Preliminary Proposals for Innovative Curricular Projects. Some of our data are consistent with this hypothesis: of men and women who do submit Maker Portfolios – that is, of those who already identify as Makers – they are equivalently likely to want to major in engineering (85.9% of men against 83.9% of women). Similar to the MIT Application, we ask you the questions we want to know. Admission Undergraduate Admission. Chris Peterson, Hal Abelson. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. It definitely sets you apart from the … 100% Upvoted. MIT's robust applicant pool actually slightly over performs the general population, as approximately 25% of our applicants who reported taking APCS in high school are women, but still, only ~26% of our female applicants self-reported taking a coding course in high school, lagging ~32% of male applicants. Below is the data for the prospective Class of 2019 (entering fall 2015) that we published last year, and the data for the prospective Class of 2020 (entering fall 2016). POPULAR SEARCHES: Arduino; CNC; Raspberry Pi; Woodworking; 3D Printing; IOT; Robot; Maker Faire; NEW Maker Campus! There is also no Ethernet … We are open to considering anything that can be done to help, and welcome your suggestions (addressed to chris.peterson@mit.edu, ccing hal@mit.edu) to that end. in MIT Admissions Maker Portfolios. Shop. Each year, the Massachusetts Institute of Technology receives nearly 20,000 applications from high school hopefuls. Of the 3414 females last year who wanted to major in engineering (61.4% of all women), 130 submitted a maker portfolio (3.8% of all women). 3. On this point, we can't help but notice the striking mirror-image quality of the Maker Portfolio and Art/Architecture portfolios compared by portfolio submission rates within gender, and wonder again about gendered associations of “making” vs. other modes of creative expression. You'll probably be happy wherever you end up. save hide report. For example, in 2014, MIT accepted 1,447 applicants from 18,356 candidates. Discover About MIT The MIT education Life & culture Learn more Apply Understanding the process Preparing for MIT First … Yet another way to look at the same data: of the 9531 male applicants last year who indicated engineering as a field of interest (74.7% of all men), 812 submitted a maker portfolio (8.5% of all men). The acceptance rate for its 9,557 Early Action applicants was just 6.9% through the Early Action program. But few, if any, colleges and universities have created instruments and processes to identify and evaluate technical creativity and skill with comparable rigor. Another possibility is that the association of a Maker Portfolio with specifically technical creativity (as opposed to more general artistic creativity) may be dissuading young women from submitting one. Application Question. r/ApplyingToCollege: This subreddit is for anyone looking for advice about college admissions, including college essays, scholarships, SAT/ACT test … Press J to jump to the feed. Selection is based on outstanding academic achievement as well as a strong match between the applicant … On the other hand, question 46 on MIT’s 2015 Undergraduate Enrolled Student Survey (ESS) asked members of the MIT Class of 2018 to indicate what, if any, identities resonated with them. … Close • Posted by 5 minutes ago. log in sign up. While submitting a Maker Portfolio is neither necessary nor sufficient for an aspiring applicant, an outstanding Maker Portfolio can provide a compelling reason to admit an otherwise qualified candidate to the Institute. First of all, this question is impossible to answer. After another admissions cycle, we regret to report that the patterns have not changed much. We believe the Maker Portfolio has improved our assessment of these applicants and offers us a competitive advantage over our peers who have not developed the processes to identify and evaluate this kind of talent. Applicants can submit various kinds of portfolios -- research papers, video/audio of music or theater performances, art or architecture, and "maker" … Many colleges and universities, including MIT, have long offered applicants the opportunity to share their talents in the admissions application in domains such as music, art, and sports. Application Question. Log in or sign up to leave a comment log in sign up. Initial Problem: No Wi-Fi in my room. Report Save. July 2017. You should know . Also -- it will probably give you a good laugh! . In my hostel, there is a Wi-Fi hotspot available for use in the common area of the floor, but it does not reach the rooms. Imagine that you get into an elevator with Mark Zuckerberg. 1. Teaching this fall? Specifically, we observed that women submitted the Maker Portfolio – and only the Maker Portfolio – at a lower rate than men, and far below the rates … Back in 2013, MIT started encouraging applicants to submit a “Maker portfolio” in addition to their application. Obviously, computer science is not the only mode of “making.” It is, however, a mode of making that has: a) comparatively good public data available, and b) a great deal of public attention currently invested in expanding the pipeline. Check it Out TODAY! However, the persistence of this pattern, despite several years of prior work to improve representation and reach targeted populations, leaves us questioning what other dynamics may be in play. Maker Campus. As many as 4,653 were international applicants, and 135 (2.9 percent) were admitted. Hey, I've been having trouble finding example technical documentation for the maker portfolio. Over the last two years, more than 2000 students have used it to show us the things they make, from surfboards to solar cells, code to cosplay, prosthetics to particle accelerators. Dawn Wendell, Assistant Director of Admissions at MIT, said that a new Maker Portfolio supplement on the MIT Admissions web site will provide a structured way for students to submit information about a diverse set of … We welcome suggestions of resources (e.g., people and/or money) that might support this kind of research to: chris.peterson@mit.edu, cc:ing hal@mit.edu. this video will remind you of your successful 2019 MIT application and all the work you put into it. Despite recent public awareness and renewed initiatives such as Girls Who Code, the STEM “pipeline” remains tightly constricted by gender. According to statistics of the class entering in the fall of 2017, there were 20,247 freshmen applicants, but only 1,452 admits (acceptance rate 7.2 percent). As we approach the next admissions cycle, the Admissions Office is continuing to work on improving representation and recruitment, including an initiative, in partnership with Maker Media, that will leverage their intellectual property and community of Maker Faires with admissions' database of prospective students to help encourage more women to take up “making” and identify as makers. Excuse the poor audio and video quality. Applicants included 15,594 US citizens or permanent residents, and 1,317 (8.4 percent) were admitted. Please answer a brief questionnaire about your research and provide a letter of recommendation from your research mentor. More than 6,000 hopefuls were deferred to regular decision. It’s a Maker Portfolio, ... At MIT Admissions, we recruit and enroll a talented and diverse class of undergraduates who will learn to use science, technology, and other areas of scholarship to serve the nation and the world in the 21st century. One persistent challenge to the Maker Portfolio, however, is the fact that women submit them at a much lower rate than men do, and at a much lower rate than they submit other portfolios and apply to MIT overall, as depicted on the chart below. For example, at Harvard the overall acceptance rate is 4.59%, compared to an acceptance rate of 14.5% for Early Action applicants. Dr. Another way of looking at the same data is that 7.4% of all men who applied to MIT last year submitted a Maker Portfolio, while only 2.8% of all women did. In that survey, 30% of respondents identified as “maker,” and the rate was the same for both men and women who responded. One reason could be that adolescent women applying to MIT don't have (or do not believe they have) the portfolio of work that a Maker Portfolio is supposed to showcase. If your top choice is MIT, don't let that possibility get away by potentially binding yourself to a school that you're not as happy with. If you have worked on more than one research project, we recommend focusing on the project that is most important to you. Over the last few decades, MIT has made great strides in leveling the playing field for women at the Institute. They really like to see people making actual, useful applications rather than gimmicky stuff like game dev and web design (you'd be surprised how many people write that they "started a … The selection process at MIT is holistic and student centered: each application is evaluated within its unique context. Our understanding would probably be improved by additional qualitative work, including (but not limited to) interviews with enrolling women who did or did not submit maker portfolios and other fieldwork that might trace the web of reasons that influence whether and which portfolios are submitted by applicants. MIT Maker Portfolio? As you can see, 85.9% of all Maker Portfolios last year were submitted by men, and only 14.1% by women. MIT Undergraduate Admissions If you are a high school student or first-year undergraduate student interested in studying Architecture or Design at MIT and would like additional information about our architecture and design majors, minors, and concentrations, please contact Paul Pettigrew (Director, Undergraduate & Alumni Outreach, Career Development) paulpett@mit.edu . popular-all-random-users | news-AskReddit-funny-pics-todayilearned-worldnews-aww-gaming-Jokes-tifu-Showerthoughts-videos-personalfinance -gifs-mildlyinteresting-explainlikeimfive-movies … The Maker Movement overall has occasionally been criticized for its lack of demographic diversity: as former MIT Professor Leah Buechley noted in a 2013 talk at Stanford on her study of representations of makers in media, 85% of the people featured on the cover of MAKE magazine in her study were men, and (to its credit) Maker Media, the organizational entity supporting the Maker Movement, has been grappling publicly with how to diversify the Maker population. It is a … Happy to say I'm part of MIT's class of 2023 (admitted EA)! An Update on Gender Imbalance in MIT Admissions Maker Portfolios. We solicited advice from readers and took additional steps to increase the representation of women and the diversity of projects featured in public presentations and portfolio materials. Archived. Close. Search. r/ApplyingToCollege. The portfolio is meant to showcase projects that they’ve built or been involved with in some form. Researchers may include a PDF of their abstract, poster, or research pape… Only 8% of them get a MIT acceptance letter. MIT Maker Portfolio? Last November, we recorded in these pages a notable difference in the rates at which men and women submitted Maker Portfolios as supplements to their freshman applications. … jump to content. Share #7. sneharams 107 replies 12 threads Junior Member. . Magazine. Forego binding early decision. It has been long-established that fewer women feel confident about their ability to succeed in engineering than in other areas of math and science. The acceptance rate last year is rumored to have been 5-10%, compared to close to 20% for GT. That is why the questions are very specific. Twenty years ago, the Final Report on Women Undergraduate Enrollment in Electrical Engineering and Computer Science at MIT, chaired by Professor Abelson, found that women were systematically less confident about their preparation to succeed in EECS than their male counterparts; last semester, a team of EECS undergraduates, in a survey of their classmates, found that "difference in confidence in the major is disproportionately higher than the difference in prior preparation [between women and men]." The Maker Portfolio is an opportunity for students to showcase their projects that require creative insight, technical skill and a ‘hands-on’ approach to learning by doing. Make: Projects. This was my Maker Portfolio for MIT. Specifically, we observed that women submitted the Maker Portfolio – and only the Maker Portfolio – at a lower rate than men, and far below the rates that they submit any other type of supplemental portfolio or apply to MIT overall. Sort by. As shown in the figure above, the gap between the proportion of men and women who submitted Maker Portfolios closed by .6%, and the rate at which female applicants submitted Maker Portfolios increased by .6%, shifts that closely track the .5% delta in overall application rates. Students who have worked on a significant research project outside of high school classes are welcome to submit a research supplement via SlideRoom. MIT Maker Portfolio Wi-Fi Extender and Load-balancer Julius Putra Tanu Setiaji (Applicant ID 1819569) Note: screenshots and pictures are only taken from the final revision of the system. Any improvement is a good thing, but it's a bit discouraging that, despite efforts to better represent the diversity of people and projects we wish to encounter in the Maker Portfolio, the needle hasn't moved as much as we would like. Members of the MIT Engineering Advisory Board review all Maker Portfolios. The Institute admitted 1,419 students to next year’s freshman class. A5) Think of the Maker Portfolio as an “elevator pitch” about your Maker projects. This is a video for MIT Admissions officers as a part of my supplemental maker portfolio for freshmen admissions for the MIT Class of 2020. So it's also possible that technically creative women may still not believe that the Maker Portfolio is “for them,” despite specific actions taken by Admissions to try and counteract this belief, e.g., by prominently featuring female makers and their projects during public talks about the Maker Portfolio at World Maker Faire New York in 2014 and 2015.